ad
Back To Top

Case Law and Legal Doctrine: How Are They Used in Legal Research?

August 14, 2023 | Quebec

Knowing Where to Look for Information to Better Analyze a Legal Question

When a legal question arises, knowing the law is not always enough. It may also be necessary to understand how courts have interpreted certain rules or to consult analyses published by legal experts.

 

This is where case law and legal doctrine come into play as two important sources of information in legal research.

 

For paralegals, knowing how to distinguish among these resources, conduct database searches, and present the results can be part of supporting the handling of a legal file.

 

These skills have a specific place in CDI College's Paralegal Technology – JCA.1F program. The Legal Interpretation and Methodology course covers research into case law and legal doctrine. In contrast, the Computerized Legal Research course introduces students to legal databases and to presenting research results.

 

What Is Case Law?

Case law generally refers to decisions rendered by courts.

 

A court decision provides more than the outcome of a dispute. It can also show how a court examined a situation, which factors it considered, and how certain rules of law were applied.

 

Conducting relevant research, therefore, requires the ability to identify decisions related to the legal question being examined.

 

In the Paralegal Technology – JCA.1F program, students learn to recognize the characteristics of a judgment, understand the functions and jurisdiction of courts, and use references that identify a decision.

 

This knowledge provides an essential foundation for methodically navigating case law.

 

Why Consult Court Decisions?

Consider a research assignment involving a specific legal question. Legislation may provide part of the answer, but it can also be useful to determine how courts have applied or interpreted the relevant provisions in different situations.

 

Case law research can help identify decisions that may shed light on the question being examined.

 

For paralegals, the objective is not to formulate a legal opinion based on these decisions. Instead, their role may involve conducting the requested research, selecting relevant information, and presenting it in a structured manner to the legal professional responsible for the file.

 

This distinction is important: finding legal information and providing legal advice are not the same task.

 

👉 Learn more: Computerized Legal Research: An Essential Skill in Paralegal Technology

 

What Is Legal Doctrine?

Legal doctrine differs from case law.

 

While case law consists of decisions rendered by courts, legal doctrine encompasses texts devoted to the study and analysis of law.

 

In the Paralegal Technology – JCA.1F program, students learn to recognize the characteristics of legal doctrine and use research methods to locate it. Researching legal doctrine is also part of the Computerized Legal Research course.

 

Legal doctrine, therefore, provides another way to explore a legal question in greater depth.

 

It does not replace legislation or court decisions. Instead, it is an additional resource that can help provide a better understanding of a legal concept, principle, or question.

 

Legislation, Case Law, and Legal Doctrine: What's the Difference?

These three sources do not serve the same purpose in legal research.

 

Legislation provides access to rules established through statutes and regulations. Case law makes it possible to examine decisions rendered by courts. Legal doctrine, meanwhile, provides analyses of the law.

 

One of the skills developed in paralegal technology is the ability to recognize different sources of law and understand their respective roles.

 

The Legal Interpretation and Methodology course covers identifying and hierarchizing sources of positive law, researching the appropriate legislation based on the facts, and researching case law and legal doctrine.

 

Legal research is therefore not simply about knowing how to search. It also requires an understanding of what to look for and why a particular source may be relevant.

 

How Are Case Law and Legal Doctrine Found?

Much of today's legal research is conducted using digital tools.

 

The 60-hour Computerized Legal Research course introduces students to various legal databases and to conducting research within them. The course outline includes researching legislation and legal doctrine, as well as presenting research results and legal reasoning.

 

Effective research, however, involves more than entering a few words into a search engine.

 

The legal question needs to be defined, appropriate search terms selected, results reviewed, and the sources that actually address the needs of the file identified.

 

The ability to modify or refine a search when it produces too many or too few results can be particularly useful.

 

Why Is It Important to Understand a Case Citation?

Court decisions need to be identified precisely.

 

The program, therefore, covers case citations, the characteristics of judgments, their functions, and the jurisdiction of courts.

 

This knowledge helps paralegals identify the information needed to locate a decision and cite it correctly as part of an assigned task.

 

It can also help organize results when research involves multiple decisions.

 

The course outline includes creating a table of cases, demonstrating the importance placed not only on finding legal information but also on presenting it in a structured manner.

 

How Do You Determine Whether a Research Result Is Relevant?

Finding a court decision or a legal text does not automatically mean it answers the research question.

 

Legal research involves making connections among the facts, the question under examination, and the identified sources.

 

Students, therefore, learn to find the appropriate legislation based on the facts presented and, in the computerized research course, to present their research results and legal reasoning.

 

This step is fundamental.

 

A search that produces dozens of documents without identifying which ones are genuinely useful can still be difficult to use. The quality of legal research, therefore, depends as much on the relevance of the results as on the number of results found.

 

Why Is Organizing Research Results Important?

Legal research needs to be understandable and useful to the person receiving it.

 

This is why the program goes beyond simply locating sources.

 

In addition to preparing a table of cases, the Legal Interpretation and Methodology course includes creating a bibliography. The Computerized Legal Research course also addresses how research results are presented.

 

Paralegals, therefore, need to be able to organize the information they gather so that it can be consulted efficiently.

 

This ability involves several qualities that are important in the legal field, including method, accuracy, analytical skills, and attention to detail.

 

👉 Learn more: Organization, Accuracy, and File Management: Essential Skills in Paralegal Technology

 

Is Legal Research Used Across Different Areas of Law?

Yes. Research methods are not limited to one type of legal file.

 

The Paralegal Technology – JCA.1F program covers several areas, including the law of obligations, family law, business law, civil procedure, criminal law, labour law, administrative law, and notarial law.

 

Legal research can therefore become a transferable skill applicable to many different legal questions.

 

A paralegal may need to research legislation for one file and a court decision for another. The nature of the sources may change, but method, accuracy, and the ability to present results clearly remain essential.

 

👉 Learn more: What Areas of Law Are Covered in Paralegal Technology?

 

A Skill That Goes Far Beyond a Simple Online Search

At first glance, legal research may seem relatively straightforward: formulate a question and find documents containing the right words.

 

In practice, it requires a more methodical approach.

 

Paralegals need to distinguish between different sources, understand the structure of a judgment, research relevant legislation, locate case law and legal doctrine, and then organize the results so they can be used effectively.

 

CDI College's Paralegal Technology – JCA.1F program allows students to develop these skills through courses focusing on legal methodology and computerized legal research.

 

For future paralegals, these skills can help them contribute to the research required for many types of legal files, regardless of the area of law involved.

 

FAQ

1. What is the difference between case law and legal doctrine?
Case law consists of decisions rendered by courts, while legal doctrine encompasses texts devoted to the study and analysis of law. The Paralegal Technology – JCA.1F program teaches students to recognize their characteristics and use appropriate methods to research them.

 

2. Do students learn how to conduct computerized legal research in the program?
Yes. A 60-hour course is devoted to computerized legal research. Students explore various legal databases, research sources such as legislation and legal doctrine, and learn how to present their research findings.

 

3. Why is legal research important for paralegals?
It allows them to locate and organize information that can support the handling of a legal file. The training develops skills such as identifying relevant legislation based on the facts, researching case law and legal doctrine, and presenting the results in a structured manner.

 

Explore Further

👉 Paralegal Technology: Understanding the Field and Career Opportunities in Quebec

 

👉 Do You Have the Right Profile to Work in Paralegal Technology?

 

👉 Legal Writing: Learning to Prepare Professional Documents

 

👉 Learn More About CDI College's Paralegal Technology – JCA.1F Program

Would you like to get more information or apply?

Info Banner Background Image